The effectiveness of zero-tolerance policies in the workplace has always been a topic of debate. Their benefits? They can help you increase productivity, save money, prevent all types of workplace harassment and sexual harassment, curb bad behavior, and reduce stress levels by encouraging your employees to work together rather than against each other.
Their pitfalls? While they're meant to eliminate any gray area in the workplace, they can also create a culture of fear. Rather than keep employees safe and productive, these types of policies can often lead to bad business decisions that affect morale, productivity, and even customer satisfaction.
For this reason, employers and managers are often hesitant to enforce zero-tolerance policies.
In this article, we'll discuss what a zero-tolerance policy is, why you should consider adopting such a policy in your workplace, and what issues may arise from enforcing it.
Get An Instant Free Course Preview
Try our best-in-class, interactive, and engaging courses for free!
What is a Zero Tolerance Policy?
Generally, a zero-tolerance policy is used to describe an "all-or-nothing" approach to problems.
In the workplace, such policies involve taking action against employees for even minor instances of misconduct or rule-breaking. The idea is that by enforcing consequences that show little tolerance for exceptions, your company will create a safe workplace and productive environment where every employee knows exactly what's expected of them and what they can expect from others.
Why You Should Adopt Zero Tolerance Policies
If you're wondering whether or not zero-tolerance policies are right for your business, here are some reasons why other employers found them effective:
Ensures rules and regulations are clearly communicated to all employees
If you have a zero-tolerance policy, every single one of your employees will know what happens if they break a rule or fail to follow through on an assignment. This ensures that everyone is working from the same set of guidelines and reduces the chance that someone will be reprimanded for something they didn't know was wrong.
Increases employee accountability
Because your employees know the consequences of breaking a rule, they're encouraged to do everything possible to avoid such punishments. If they see someone else getting in trouble for something that appears innocuous, however, this encourages them to help take action before further infractions occur.
Promotes pride and camaraderie among co-workers
No one wants to be seen as "that guy," so when an employee sees their peers getting reprimanded for a mistake he or she makes on a project, they'll feel compelled to step up and prevent the same thing from happening again. This helps foster good working relationships between team members because everyone is aware of what's going on at all times.
Allows you to manage employee performance more effectively
With a policy in place that holds everyone accountable, you can easily monitor the performance of each member of your team and provide appropriate feedback that will help them improve. The policies also allow you to remove any members who aren't a good fit for your business without having to go through a long termination process.
Pitfalls of Zero Tolerance Policies
Here are some reasons why a zero-tolerance policy may not be right for you:
Employees may feel they have no room for error
Tough policies can make people feel like there's no room for error when in reality mistakes happen all the time. People slip up sometimes; it's part of being human.
When your employees know that even small mistakes or oversights can get them in trouble, they'll often do everything possible to avoid working on anything that might put their job at risk. This creates an us-versus-them mentality where everyone feels like management is trying to catch them slipping up so it's easy for morale and productivity levels to drop. They may create a culture of fear rather than teamwork among employees
When every single action you make can be scrutinized, it's easy for employees to become frustrated and resentful towards you and each other. This leads to a culture where people are more concerned with placing blame than finding solutions, which can harm your business as a whole. They may be difficult to uphold in the event of a legal challenge
Many companies include language in their zero-tolerance policies, allowing managers to use their discretion when handling certain types of infractions. These policies are designed to ensure that everyone is treated consistently, regardless of appearance or other personal biases, while also allowing you to show leniency toward employees if needed. Discover ways on how to combat unconscious biases by having your employees take the quiz for unconscious bias here.
Maintaining a culture where people feel safe admitting when they're struggling or asking for assistance from others is one of the best ways to encourage employees to do their best work.
Creates a culture of fear rather than accountability
Without fail, employees often fear consequences that never come. This can create a culture of paranoia where people are constantly on edge because they're worried about doing something wrong when in reality there's little chance anything will happen to them if they slip up. Without the support of management, the morale of your team will suffer and productivity levels may begin to decline as well.
It can be difficult for employees who genuinely need more time or assistance with an assignment but don't want to ask for it due to fears that they'll end up getting in trouble anyway. If you have strict rules about asking for too many things or taking too long before completing work, this policy may not help you achieve what you're looking for with your team.
It can be difficult for employees who genuinely need more time or assistance with an assignment but don't want to ask for it due to fears that they'll end up getting in trouble anyway.
Can lead to conflicts when they're vague
Problems can arise when a violation of a zero-tolerance policy isn't clear-cut. It's possible that an employee had no idea they were doing something wrong or unintentionally made a mistake that led to your company losing money or otherwise suffering some type of harm.
If you want to avoid any gray areas concerning your policies, it may be helpful for you to create separate guidelines for minor infractions and major ones so that you're able to address each case accordingly.
Generally speaking, however, it's always better to enforce stricter rules than looser ones because this will help prevent problems before they happen. For example, if there are strict guidelines about how work should be handled and submitted, for example, this can prevent your team from turning in late or incomplete assignments and avoid wasting time and money as a result.
The Right Way to Enforce Zero Tolerance Policies
When it comes time to enforce zero-tolerance policies in the workplace, here are some dos and don'ts you should keep in mind:
Conduct an audit before implementing a new policy
Before anything else, see how many rules and regulations apply to your employees and whether or not they're being enforced on a regular basis. That's why a compliance audit from HR is necessary. If there are too many for anyone but HR staff to keep track of, then creating a zero-tolerance policy may not be feasible.
It's also important to keep track of your employees' feedback on the current rules and regulations that are already in place. You can use this information to create a zero-tolerance policy that everyone is comfortable with.
Follow Department of Labor guidelines for documenting infractions
If you plan to enforce consequences for violations of existing company policies or procedures, it's important that you clearly document each employee's transgressions so you have evidence if there ever ends up being an issue with discipline or performance reviews down the road. If possible, try to ensure that every manager who oversees the individual is involved in taking disciplinary action as well.
Don't overlook minor infractions
It's common for managers to let small slip-ups slide without severe consequences because they don't want employees becoming even more discouraged by constantly being reprimanded for things beyond their control. However, this defeats the purpose of a zero-tolerance policy. Unless the infraction is something you consider trivial, such as forgetting to wear your nametag on casual Fridays, not filling out your timesheet properly, or harassing a coworker on social media, be sure to tell employees that there will be some form of punishment if it happens again.
Don't try to enforce policies with threats alone
It's easy for managers and HR staff to make threats about disciplinary actions when an employee breaks a rule, but threats won't do anything if they aren't enforced. Employees will quickly catch on to this and start choosing which rules they're willing to break just so they can get away with more down the road.
Instead, take action immediately after each violation occurs and listen intently while employees explain their point of view about what happened. It's also a good idea to keep employees in the loop about any policies that are being considered so they can give their input and ensure that there aren't any misunderstandings later on.
Enforcing policies without being overly-authoritarian
When you enforce rules and regulations, it's easy for your actions to come across as overly authoritarian. However, there are ways you can implement these policies without making workers feel like children:
• Introduce new rules gradually, one at a time, so employees have the opportunity to adjust • Give specific examples of how a particular rule was broken instead of being vague or general • Providing reasons why certain actions violate existing policies, even if they're just educated guesses
Don't punish employees for not knowing policies exist
Ignorance is not a defense. If you aren't following a policy that's already been established and it affects your work performance, then you should know about the consequences. However, it isn't OK to punish an employee who didn't know about a policy because it wasn't posted in the break room or printed on his paycheck. In this case, let him off with a warning and make sure he knows where to go from there.
Don't enforce a policy with no explanation
When you're first implementing policies, make sure you explain each infraction in detail so employees understand exactly where they went wrong and why it's not acceptable according to workplace standards. This will reduce confusion about what is expected of them and how you expect them to behave.
Don't treat every violation as a major offense regardless of its severity
While some actions are definitely more severe than others, it's always best for employers to keep an open mind when enforcing policies. If somebody breaks a rule that only comes around once or twice per year, or if somebody makes an honest mistake that doesn't require drastic disciplinary action, consider giving them a warning or simply telling them to be more careful next time.
Be efficient when determining policy violations
It's standard for employers to make sure employees understand exactly what will result in an infraction before formalizing a policy, but it's also important that they know how violations will be determined if something happens. Here are a few tips to help you enforce policies without going overboard:
Don't take disciplinary action unless the entire incident has been thoroughly investigated
In most cases, managers should not jump straight into disciplinary measures as soon as an infraction occurs. If there isn't enough evidence to determine who's at fault, wait until both parties have had the chance to explain their version of events and weigh out all of your options before taking action.
Don't hold back on discipline if the situation is severe
While most policies are implemented to keep workers in check, some violations might warrant immediate disciplinary action if they endanger the lives of your employees or cause extensive financial damage. For example, you should consider termination for any employee that steals from your company or attempts to cover up a crime.
Enforce policies consistently across all employees regardless of position, rank, etc.
Everyone has heard horror stories about how some companies use certain perks and benefits as bargaining chips when disciplining their employees; don't be like them! Ensure that every single worker is held accountable for their actions by handing out punishments on a case-by-case basis instead of making exceptions for individuals based on their position. This is why all companies should also have a solid anti-bribery and corruption policy.
Always consider the circumstances of an infraction before deciding on punishment
If you're asking yourself, "How severe is this infraction compared to others I've seen?", chances are that you're falling into a trap that many employers fall into using punitive measures as a one-size-fits-all solution to ensure everyone is treated equally. However, it's more effective to consider personal factors like intent and severity when determining punishments so employees understand why they were punished instead of simply getting reprimanded for breaking policy.
Consider talking with employees about what happened after disciplinary action has been taken
Some people do not agree with zero tolerance policies because they feel like these policies can damage their reputation in the eyes of management giving them a difficult time when it comes to future interactions. Sometimes waiting until the heat is off (and all disciplinary action has been taken) to talk with employees about what happened can allow them to learn from their mistakes and prevent further alienation.
Final thoughts
If you want an effective workplace where everything runs smoothly and productivity levels are high, creating protocols for disciplinary action may be beneficial but shouldn't be the only thing on your agenda.
To achieve employee engagement and efficiency at work, you should also be focusing on other aspects of the business. For example, it's important to create an environment where employees feel comfortable asking questions and interacting with others about their work to ensure that they're getting all the information they need in order to do things right.
